What Is Christian Empathy, and Why Is it under Fire for Being “Toxic?”

In recent years, some voices—both within and outside the Christian community—have begun to scrutinize empathy, coining the term “toxic empathy.” But what does this term mean, and why is it being levied against a principle so central to Christ’s teaching?

4 Defining Factors of 'Toxic Empathy'

1. Over-Identification and Self-Sacrifice

Critics argue that when empathy is taken to an extreme, it can lead to a dangerous blurring of personal boundaries. This “toxic” form of empathy may drive individuals to over-identify with the suffering of others to the point of self-neglect. In the Christian context, this is seen as a kind of unhealthy martyrdom—a pattern where one’s own well-being is sacrificed in an unsustainable attempt to alleviate others' pain. The truth of Scripture reminds us that while we are called to bear one another’s burdens (Galatians 6:2 NKJV), we are also instructed to “guard our hearts” (Proverbs 4:23 NKJV).

2. Enabling Harmful Behaviors

Another concern is that excessive empathy can inadvertently enable harmful behaviors. In environments where unguarded compassion leads to the excusing of destructive actions—whether within families or church communities—empathy may unwittingly foster dependency and a lack of accountability. What begins as a compassionate gesture can sometimes become a means of perpetuating negative cycles, contrary to the transformative message of repentance and renewal found throughout Scripture.

3. The Paradox of Compassionate Judgment

There exists an ironic tension within Christian empathy. The very empathy that calls believers to love unconditionally can be twisted into a tool for moral judgment. When empathy is applied selectively—extending grace to some while withholding it from others—it risks creating an “in-group” and “out-group” mentality. This selective compassion is at odds with the universal love that Christ demonstrated, as He said, “A new commandment I give to you, that you love one another; as I have loved you, that you also love one another” (John 13:34 NKJV).

4. Emotional Exhaustion and Burnout

On a personal level, the burden of unrelenting empathy can lead to emotional exhaustion. Continually absorbing the pain of others without adequate boundaries can result in a state of burnout. This form of toxic empathy not only compromises individual well-being but can also weaken the collective strength of a church community, rendering it less effective in its ministry.

Photo Credit: Getty Images/AaronAmat

The tension between radical compassion and the need for healthy boundaries is not a modern phenomenon. Early Christian communities were known for their radical love—sharing everything in common, caring for the poor, and embracing a counter-cultural sense of unity (Acts 2:44-45 NKJV). Yet, even these communities wrestled with maintaining order and protecting the vulnerable. In times of persecution and hardship, acts of empathy sometimes led to self-sacrifice that bordered on self-destruction—a paradox that still challenges believers today.

Consider the example of martyrdom, celebrated as the ultimate act of faith and empathy. The early church revered the sacrifice of its members, often overlooking the personal cost in the name of God’s love. Today, while the forms have changed, the struggle to balance self-care with selfless service remains.

What Is the Psychological Perspective on Empathy?

From a psychological standpoint, empathy is both vital and volatile. Studies in psychology and neuroscience reveal that while empathy is crucial for connection, it must be moderated to prevent emotional overload. Unchecked empathy can lead to “emotional contagion,” where one absorbs another’s distress to a debilitating degree.

Within Christian communities, where empathy is deeply embedded in spiritual practice, there is a risk that believers may conflate emotional absorption with genuine compassion. This over-identification can lead not only to burnout but also to impaired judgment, making it challenging to discern when support crosses into enabling harmful behavior. The truth is that healthy empathy requires boundaries—guidelines that preserve both the caregiver’s and the recipient’s well-being.

Photo Credit: ©GettyImages/fizkes

How can Christians practice empathy compassionately and sustainably?

Embrace Self-Compassion

Caring for oneself is not contrary to the call of Christian empathy. Scripture teaches us to “Love Your Neighbor as Yourself” (Mark 12:31 NKJV), implicitly affirming that self-care is essential. Jesus came to give us life in abundance (John 10:10 NKJV), a promise that includes nurturing our spiritual, emotional, and physical well-being.

Develop Healthy Boundaries

Setting boundaries is not an act of selfishness but of wisdom. It means understanding and respecting our limitations and recognizing when to say “no.” Boundaries help channel our empathy effectively, preserving our ability to serve others without depleting our strength. Proverbs 4:23 reminds us to “guard your heart,” a principle that applies to our emotional and spiritual lives.

Foster Accountability

Within our communities, accountability is key. Honest, respectful dialogue about the impact of certain behaviors on individuals and the community helps maintain a balance between compassion and necessary correction. We prevent empathy from morphing into enabling behavior by fostering an environment where truth is spoken in love (Ephesians 4:15 NKJV).

Encourage Mutual Care

Empathy is most powerful when it is reciprocal. Christian communities thrive when there is a mutual exchange of care, where every member gives and receives support. This balanced approach prevents the isolation of any single individual and reinforces the biblical principle of bearing one another’s burdens (Galatians 6:2 NKJV).

Seek Wisdom from Scripture and Tradition

The Bible and centuries of Christian thought provide a robust framework for understanding and practicing empathy. Passages like Proverbs offer practical advice on Discernment, while the life of Jesus provides a model of compassion that is both radical and measured. We align our empathy with God's will by grounding our actions in the truth of Scripture.

Photo Credit: ©iStock/Getty Images Plus/Prostock-Studio

The conversation surrounding “toxic empathy” extends beyond the walls of our churches and into the broader cultural discourse. It challenges us to reevaluate how we value emotional labor, the importance of self-care, and the need for clear boundaries in all relationships. While some critics argue that labeling empathy as “toxic” undermines its transformative power, others see it as a necessary caution in our emotionally charged world.

This critique calls us to refine, not reject, the concept of empathy. In our quest to follow Christ’s example, we must cultivate a form of empathy that is robust, resilient, and free from the pitfalls of over-identification. The call is not to abandon compassion but to practice it in a way that honors both the recipient and the giver.

Christian empathy, at its best, is a mighty force for good—a reflection of the divine love that calls us to see the face of God in every person. It is a call to reach out to the hurting, celebrate with joy, and transform pain into hope. However, even the most noble virtues require wisdom and Discernment. The critique of “toxic empathy” reminds us that our most compassionate impulses can become self-destructive without proper boundaries. As believers, we are challenged to reflect deeply on our practices. Are we giving so selflessly that we lose ourselves? Are we setting boundaries that protect us while still extending grace to others? These questions are not easy, yet they are vital for building communities that truly reflect the love of Christ.

Let us strive for transformative and sustainable empathy—a compassion that honors the dignity of everyone, including ourselves. By embracing both our shared humanity and the necessity of self-care, we can reclaim the true spirit of Christian empathy. In doing so, we ensure that our compassionate actions remain a source of healing and hope rather than a catalyst for burnout. The truth is clear: Our journey toward balanced empathy is a profound act of faith. It invites us to engage with every layer of our humanity—raw and unfiltered—in the light of God’s Word (NKJV). May we step forward with courage, guided by the strength of Scripture, and build bridges of unity and love that lead to a more just, caring, and connected world.

Photo Credit: ©Pexels/Oladimeji Ajegbile